Back in 2012, the US Supreme Court ruled that it’s illegal for the police to attach a GPS tracking device to someone’s car without a warrant. But what if you find a GPS tracking device on your car? Can you remove it?
This story originally appeared on Ars Technica, a trusted source for technology news, tech policy analysis, reviews, and more. Ars is owned by WIRED’s parent company, Condé Nast.
A little more than a year ago, the state of Indiana charged a suspected drug dealer with theft for removing a government-owned GPS tracking device from his SUV. This month, the state’s Supreme Court began considering the case, and some justices seemed skeptical of the government’s argument.
“I’m really struggling with how is that theft,” said Justice Steven David during recent oral arguments.
One Time in Warrick County
The case began in July 2018, when the Warrick County Sheriff’s Office got a warrant to attach a GPS tracking device to Derek Heuring’s car. Information from a confidential informant had led them to believe that Heuring was using the vehicle to sell meth.
The GPS device transmitted data for a little more than a week. Then it stopped. Officers suspected Heuring had discovered and removed it.
After waiting another 10 days to see if it would start working again, detectives applied for a warrant to search Heuring’s home and a nearby property belonging to Heuring’s parents. US law requires law enforcement to show probable cause that a crime had been committed before engaging in a search. In this case, police said they suspected that Heuring had committed the crime of theft by taking the GPS device.
Police did find the tracking device. They also found methamphatamine and drug paraphernalia—evidence that police say show that Heuring had been dealing drugs.
So Heuring was charged both with drug dealing and with theft of the GPS device.
Is That So Wrong?
At trial, Heuring’s legal team argued that the search had been illegal because the police didn’t have probable cause to believe their client had committed theft. The defense pointed out that the device could have fallen off the car by accident or simply malfunctioned.
Even if Heuring did take the device off the vehicle, he couldn’t have known for sure that it belonged to the government. It wasn’t exactly labeled as the property of the Warrick County Sheriff’s Office. Most important, it’s not clear that taking an unwanted device off your car is theft—even if you know who it belongs to.
An appellate court ruled against Heuring in July, leading to the case reaching the Indiana Supreme Court earlier this month.
With the case now at the state’s high court, the stakes are high. If Heuring can show that the police lacked probable cause to search his house, he could get all of the evidence gathered in the search thrown out—not only evidence of GPS device theft, but evidence of drug dealing too.
Initially, multiple justices seemed skeptical of the idea that taking a tracking device off your own car amounted to theft. “If somebody wants to find me to do harm to me and it’s not the police, and they put a tracking device on my car and I find a tracking device and I dispose of it after stomping on it 25 times, I would hope they would not be able to go to a local prosecutor, and somehow I’m getting charges filed against me for destroying someone else’s property,” Justice David said.
A lawyer for the government acknowledged that it wouldn’t be theft to remove a tracking device put there by a private party. But he argued that things are different when the government has a warrant to use a tracking device. The device had a legal basis for being on the car, the lawyer argued. By removing it and preventing tracking, Heuring was depriving the government of the use of its property.
The Memorandum Decision for Heuring v. Indiana from the Indiana appeals court is available as a PDF through the state government’s website. The state Supreme Court is still considering the case after those oral arguments on November 7.
This story originally appeared on Ars Technica.
More Great WIRED Stories
- Star Wars: Beyond the Rise of Skywalker
- How the dumb design of a WWII Plane led to the Macintosh
- Hackers can use lasers to “speak” to your Amazon Echo
- Electric cars—and irrationality—just might save the stick shift
- China’s sprawling movie sets put Hollywood to shame
- 👁 A safer way to protect your data; plus, check out the latest news on AI
- ✨ Optimize your home life with our Gear team’s best picks, from robot vacuums to affordable mattresses to smart speake